The Pros and Cons of Betting on Favorites vs. Underdogs

Favorites or underdogs? Many bettors have a preference. In the past, before the Internet, public, or “square,” bettors typically bet the favorite with reckless abandon in a sports matchup. It makes sense. A bettor wants some action on the game, and they normally want go with the stronger team in a matchup. So, sharp bettors usually targeted underdogs as a result, because the sportsbooks would shade the lines or move the lines based on heavy public action on favorites. However, in the Information Age, square bettors have become savvier and target favorites and underdogs based on value. Sharp bettors have been left to mine value where they can.

Get sports picks for every league and nearly every matchup on Doc’s free picks page.

Here we will look at some of the complexities of betting favorites vs. underdogs.

Introduction

• Definition of underdogs and favorites in sports betting
• Overview of the pros and cons of betting on underdogs and favorites

Pros of betting on favorites

• Higher probability of winning bets due to better odds
• Lower risk of losing bets compared to underdogs
• Opportunities to capitalize on public perception and biases

Cons of betting on favorites

• Lower payouts compared to underdogs
• Higher betting lines, which can limit value opportunities
• Potential for upsets and unexpected losses
• Psychological factors, such as overconfidence and complacency, can influence favorite betting decisions

Pros of betting on underdogs

• Higher payouts compared to favorites
• Lower betting lines, which can lead to value opportunities
• Potential for upsets and big wins
• Opportunities to capitalize on public perception and biases

Cons of betting on underdogs

• Higher risk of losing bets due to a lower probability of winning
• Underdogs are typically less talented or less favored to win
• Limited data and information on underdogs compared to favorites
• Psychological factors, such as fear of losing and overconfidence, can influence underdog betting decisions

Strategies for betting on favorites

• Identifying undervalued favorites through statistical analysis and research
• Evaluating matchups and game situations to identify value opportunities
• Betting on favorites selectively and within a well-defined betting system or strategy
• Staying disciplined and managing bankroll to minimize losses and maximize returns

Strategies for betting on underdogs

• Identifying undervalued underdogs through statistical analysis and research
• Evaluating matchups and game situations to identify potential upsets
• Betting on underdogs selectively and within a well-defined betting system or strategy
• Staying disciplined and managing bankroll to minimize losses and maximize returns

Sport-specific strategies for betting "Chalk and Dogs"

• Importance of having a solid betting strategy for favorites and underdogs.
• Baseball:
  • Betting on favorites: Look for strong starting pitchers. (2022 L.A. Dodgers)
  • Betting on underdogs: Consider teams with hot bats or underappreciated pitching staffs. (2021 Kansas City Royals)
• Football:
  • Betting on favorites: Focus on teams with a dominant running game and strong defense. (2022 San Francisco 49ers)
  • Betting on underdogs: Look for teams with an underrated quarterback or a strong pass rush. (2022 New York Giants)
• Basketball:
  • Betting on favorites: Consider teams with strong offenses and high-scoring players. (2022-23 Philadelphia 76'ers)
  • Betting on underdogs: Look for teams with a strong bench or a disruptive defense. (2020-21 Memphis Grizzlies)
• Hockey:
  • Betting on favorites: Look for teams with a dominant power play and a strong goaltender. (2022-23 Tampa Bay Lightning)
  • Betting on underdogs: Consider teams with a hot goaltender or a strong penalty kill. (2022-23 Arizona Coyotes)
• Conclusion: Understanding each sport's unique dynamics and focusing on specific factors can increase your chances of success when betting on favorites and underdogs in baseball, football, basketball, and hockey.

Introduction to betting favorites vs. underdogs

As sports betting becomes more mainstream, it's crucial to understand the difference between betting favorites vs. the underdogs. Here are some interesting facts on favorites vs. dogs.

• From 2003 to 2023, NFL underdogs have a winning percentage of 33.3% outright. In those 20 years, NFL favorites have only covered the spread by 44.25%
• Also, from 2003 to 2023, San Antonio leads all NBA teams with an against-the-spread (ATS) mark of 672-590-30, a mark of 53.3%
• From 2018-2022, MLB favorites have a 7,469-5,530 (57.5%) record, with the money line being an average of -142.

"Playing it safe" - Pros of betting the favorite

Betting on favorites is a common sports betting strategy. These are teams that are expected to win, based on their rankings, past performance, and other factors. Here are some of the pros of betting on favorites:

• Higher probability of winning bets due to better odds: Favorites are typically given better odds to win, meaning there is a higher probability that you will win your bet if you choose to bet on them.
• Lower risk of losing bets compared to underdogs: Since favorites are more likely to win, there is less risk involved in betting on them. This can make them a safer choice for those who are risk-averse or new to sports betting.
• Opportunities to capitalize on public perception and biases: Many people tend to bet on favorites simply because they are the popular choice. However, this can lead to biases and inaccuracies in the odds, which can present opportunities for savvy bettors to capitalize on these public perceptions and biases.

Snooze alert- Cons of betting the favorite

While there are some benefits to betting on favorites, such as higher chances of winning, there are also some cons to keep in mind:

• Lower payouts compared to underdogs: Since favorites are more likely to win, the payouts for winning bets are typically lower than for underdogs. This means that you may need to place larger bets on favorites to see a significant return on your investment.
• Higher betting lines, which can limit value opportunities: Betting lines for favorites are often set higher than for underdogs, which can limit the value opportunities for bettors. This can make it difficult to find profitable bets on favorites.
• Potential for upsets and unexpected losses: Even though favorites are expected to win, upsets and unexpected losses can still occur. This can be frustrating and costly for bettors who have placed bets on favorites.
• "Backdoor cover" In blowout games, often the favorite will rest their starters. The underdog can score a meaningless touchdown or three-pointer, causing the favorite to not cover the spread while still winning the game.

"The Dogs are Barking"- Pros of betting on the underdog

Betting on underdogs can be an attractive option for sports bettors looking to take advantage of potentially lucrative opportunities. While favorites may seem like a safer bet, there are several advantages to betting on the underdog:

• Higher payouts compared to favorites can result in big wins for those who bet on the underdog
• Lower betting lines for underdogs can create value opportunities, making it possible to win even if the underdog doesn't win the game outright
• Upsets can and do happen in sports, leading to surprising victories for underdogs and potentially large payouts for those who bet on them
• Capitalizing on public perception and biases can provide an advantage in underdog betting. If the public perceives a particular team as weak or unlikely to win, the odds may be more favorable for betting on the underdog
• The general public likes to bet favorites, which may cause the odds or spreads to become larger. Savvy bettors can take advantage of this other for public bias.

"Are you crazy??!!" Cons of betting on the underdog

While betting on underdogs can be exciting and potentially lucrative, it also comes with its own set of risks and drawbacks.

• Higher risk of losing bets due to lower probability of winning: Underdogs are called underdogs for a reason – they are typically less talented or less favored to win. Betting on them can be riskier than betting on favorites because their chances of winning are generally lower.
• Psychological factors, such as fear of losing and overconfidence, can influence underdog betting decisions: Betting on an underdog can be tempting, especially if they have a charismatic underdog story or a particularly passionate fan base. However, this emotional attachment to an underdog can cloud judgment and lead to poor betting decisions.
• Underdogs are often subject to larger betting lines, which can limit value opportunities: Since underdogs are less favored to win, they often have larger betting lines compared to favorites. This can limit the potential value opportunities for underdog bettors.

Strategies for "laying the points" (the price of a heavy favorite)

When it comes to sports betting, favorites are often seen as the safer option. But simply betting on the team with the better odds isn't always the best strategy. Here are some tips on how to bet on favorites more effectively:

Identifying undervalued favorites through statistical analysis and research

• Look beyond the win-loss record and investigate more in-depth statistics such as player efficiency ratings, offensive and defensive efficiency, and advanced metrics like true shooting percentage and PER.
• Keep track of injuries, suspensions, and lineup changes that may affect a team's performance.
• Research historical matchups between teams and how they performed in similar situations.

Evaluating matchups and game situations to identify value opportunities

• Look at factors such as home-court advantage, travel schedules, and rest days to assess a team's situation going into a game.
• Consider the strengths and weaknesses of each team and how they match up against each other.
• Evaluate how important a game is for each team. Teams with playoff aspirations may play differently than those with nothing to lose.

Betting on favorites selectively and within a well-defined betting system or strategy

• Don't bet on every favorite. Selectively choose the favorites that offer the most value based on your research.
• Have a clear betting system or strategy in place to guide your decisions. This can help prevent emotional or impulsive bets.
• Consider using a progressive betting system, such as Doc’s Sports Unit System, which adjusts the size of your bets based on the perceived edge.

Staying disciplined and managing bankroll to minimize losses and maximize returns

• Set a budget for your betting and stick to it. Only bet what you can afford to lose.
• Keep track of your bets and results to assess your performance and adjust your strategy if necessary.
• Avoid chasing losses by increasing your bet sizes in an attempt to recoup losses. Stick to your betting system and trust the process.

By following these strategies for betting on favorites, you can increase your chances of success and maximize your returns. Remember to always do your research, evaluate matchups, and stay disciplined in your betting.

Strategies for betting on "David vs. Goliath"

Betting on underdogs has the potential to be a lucrative strategy, but it necessitates thorough research and a steadfast approach to optimize your profits. The following are some techniques for effectively betting on underdogs:

Identifying undervalued underdogs through statistical analysis and research:

• Look beyond the win-loss record and investigate more in-depth statistics such as player efficiency ratings, offensive and defensive efficiency, and advanced metrics like true shooting percentage and PER.
• Keep track of injuries, suspensions, and lineup changes that may affect a team's performance.
• Research historical matchups between teams and how they performed in similar situations.

Evaluating matchups and game situations to identify potential upsets:

• Look at factors such as home-court advantage, travel schedules, and rest days to assess a team's situation going into a game.
• Consider the strengths and weaknesses of each team and how they match up against each other.
• Evaluate how important a game is for each team. Teams with playoff aspirations may play differently than those with nothing to lose.

Betting on underdogs selectively and within a well-defined betting system or strategy:

• Don't bet on every underdog. Selectively choose the underdogs that offer the most value based on your research.
• Have a clear betting system or strategy in place to guide your decisions. This can help prevent emotional or impulsive bets.
• Consider using a progressive betting system, such as Doc’s Sports Unit System, which adjusts the size of your bets based on the perceived edge.

Staying disciplined and managing bankroll to minimize losses and maximize returns:

• Set a budget for your betting and stick to it. Only bet what you can afford to lose.
• Keep track of your bets and results to assess your performance and adjust your strategy if necessary.
• Avoid chasing losses by increasing your bet sizes in an attempt to recoup losses. Stick to your betting system and trust the process.

By following these strategies for betting on underdogs, you can increase your chances of success and maximize your returns. Remember to always do your research, evaluate matchups, and stay disciplined in your betting.

Sport-specific strategies for betting "chalk and dogs" (favorites and long shots)

Betting on sports is a popular pastime for many fans, but it can be a challenging and risky endeavor. One of the keys to success is having a solid strategy for betting on both favorites (or "chalk") and underdogs (or "dogs"). Here are some sport-specific strategies to consider when betting on these two types of bets for baseball, football, basketball, and hockey.

Baseball:

• Betting on favorites: Look for strong starting pitchers, as they often set the tone for the game. Example: The 2022 L.A. Dodgers had the 2nd best runline record ATS with the 2nd most wins from their starting pitchers.
• Betting on underdogs: Consider teams with hot bats or underappreciated pitching staff. Example: Betting on the 2021 Kansas City Royals had the 5th most wins as a dog while ranking 8th in the MLB in batting avg.

Football:

• Betting on favorites: Focus on teams with a dominant running game and strong defense. Example: The 2022 San Francisco 49ers had a 13-7 ATS mark, with the 8th-best rushing attack and 1st points allowed by the defense.
• Betting on underdogs: Look for teams with an underrated quarterback or a strong pass rush. Example: Betting on the 2022 New York Giants returned a 6-5-1 mark outright as an underdog and a 14-5 ATS record overall.

Basketball:

• Betting on favorites: Consider teams with strong offenses and high-scoring players. Example: The 2022-23 Philadelphia 76'ers, with both James Harden (21.0 PPG) and Joel Embiid (33.1 PPG), had an ATS record of 48-34-1, tops in the NBA for the regular season.
• Betting on underdogs: Look for teams with a strong bench or a disruptive defense. Example: The 2020-21 Memphis Grizzlies were tied with the most wins as a dog (20) and 6th in the NBA in bench scoring.

Hockey:

• Betting on favorites: Look for teams with a dominant power play and a strong goaltender. Example: The 2022-23 Tampa Bay Lightning had the 4th most wins as a favorite with a top-tier goalie in Andrei Vasilevskiy and 3rd in power goals.
• Betting on underdogs: Consider teams with a hot goaltender or a strong penalty kill. Example: The 2022-23 Arizona Coyotes had the 6th most wins as an underdog the 2nd-best penalty-killing team.

In conclusion, betting on favorites and underdogs in sports requires a solid understanding of each sport's unique dynamics. By focusing on specific factors and looking for value opportunities, you can increase your chances of success when betting on chalk and dogs in baseball, football, basketball, and hockey.

Conclusion:

• Betting on underdogs and favorites each has its pros and cons
• Underdogs can offer the potential for big payouts, but require careful research and a disciplined approach
• Favorites are generally considered safer bets but with lower payouts
• Balancing risk and reward is key in sports betting, and requires careful consideration of odds, potential payout, and the likelihood of an outcome
• Research and analysis are essential to making informed decisions in sports betting
• Ultimately, it's up to each bettor to decide on a preferred strategy based on their risk tolerance and goals
• Whether betting on favorites or underdogs, discipline and strategic thinking are crucial for long-term success in sports betting.

FAQ:

What are the pros of betting on favorites?

Betting on favorites is generally considered a safer bet, as the odds are in favor of the favorite winning the game or match. The payouts are typically lower but more consistent.

What is an example of a favorite?

Robert Ferringo College Basketball Game of the Year

8-Unit Play. Take #786 Gonzaga (-5) over St. Mary's (10 p.m., Saturday, Feb. 25)

I think that people may be judging Gonzaga a bit too harshly this year. No, maybe they aren't the dominating juggernaut that they have been over the past five years. But they have rolled teams like Alabama, Xavier, Kentucky and Michigan State. That ain't nothing. Four of their five losses have come against Top 15 teams - all on the road or neutral sites. The Bulldogs are 19-2 in their last 21 games overall and are playing for a share of the WCC regular season title. The Bulldogs are also playing with revenge for a 78-70 loss in overtime at St. Mary's back on Feb. 4. You can’t underestimate that psychological effect.

Over the last 22 years the Bulldogs have gotten swept by St. Mary's in the regular season exactly one time (2015-16). They have lost to them twice in the same season just one other time (2012). That is just twice in 22 years that Gonzaga has lost to St. Mary's twice in the same season. Further, over the last 20 years Gonzaga has lost at home to St. Mary's just twice. The other 18 home wins have come by 24, 14, 5, 1, 11, 11, 10, 7, 19, 14, 5, 22, 21, (L), 23, (L), 48, 10, 22, and 16 points. Those Gonzaga blowouts in big games against St. Mary's are kind of par for the course. These guys have also met in the WCC playoffs 14 times in the last 20 years. And Gonzaga has beaten them by 13, 13, 25, (L), 12, (L), 14, 16, 10, 18, (L), 18, 23 and 13 points.

So the reality is that over the last two decades Gonzaga has faced St. Mary's either at home or in the WCC tournament 34 times. Big games. Gonzaga is 29-5 in those 34 meetings and 25 of those wins have come by 10 points or more. Those 29 wins have come by an average of 15.8 points per game. Gonzaga doesn't beat St. Mary's: they stomp the ever-loving s#*t out of them. Is that what's going to happen here? Yeah, I think so. It's Drew Timme's final home game, and he will leave this school as one of the most successful and beloved Bulldogs ever. You think they aren’t going all out in his final home game? Gonzaga also has the revenge angle, they have the home court edge, they have the motivation of winning a regular season title, and I just think that they are the better team. Add it together and this one shouldn’t be close.

What is an example of an underdog?

NBA Prediction from August Young

7-Unit NBA: (524) Sacramento Kings +1.5 -110 over Golden State Warriors (4/17/2023 @ 10:00PM ET) This line is ridiculous. The Kings were favored in Game 1, and pulled out the win down the stretch despite a pair of terrible performances from Domantas Sabonis, and Kevin Huerter. Sabonis went 5-17 from the field, while Huerter went 3-12, including 0-5 from three-point range. We expect both to have much better performances here tonight. The Warriors have been a mess on the road all season long with a record of 11-31. How are they being favored here, while also receiving the majority of tickets from public bettors? It's almost as though the media and public are unable to accept that this is not the same Golden State team of old. Yes, they have had plenty of injury issues and we understand that statement is not totally fair; but this Kings team will be beaming with confidence after picking up their first playoff win in more than 17 years! All we keep hearing in the main-stream media is the narrative of "Championship Pedigree" and the "Zig Zag Theory". All that talk only creates more value on the opposite side as perception skews the market. Sacramento are 45-36 (55.6%) ATS this season, which includes hitting 58.1% as an underdog. We mentioned the Warriors road struggles; but it's even worse from a spread perspective. Golden State are just 12-29 (29.3%) ATS on the road this season, which includes going just 7-15 as a favorite. They are also just 8-18 on the road in conference play. Huge value on the Kings for us, which the market seems to continue to ignore. Are we forgetting this is the best offense in the NBA with a 119.86 adjusted offensive rating? Golden State are not an elite defensive team anymore either. They rank just 18th in adjusted defensive rating, which is a recipe for disaster against the Sac-Town. Especially if Domas, and Heurter get going. LFG!

What are the cons of betting on favorites?

The primary disadvantage of betting on favorites is the lower potential payouts. Additionally, favorites can be overvalued by bookmakers, making the odds less favorable for the bettor.

What are the pros of betting on underdogs?

Betting on underdogs can offer the potential for larger payouts, as the odds are against the underdog winning. It can also be a more exciting and unpredictable experience.

What are the cons of betting on underdogs?

The main disadvantage of betting on underdogs is the lower likelihood of winning, as they are not expected to win the game or match. Additionally, it can be more challenging to research and assess the likelihood of an underdog winning.

What does +150 mean in sports betting?

+150 is a betting line that indicates the potential payout for a $100 bet on the underdog. In this case, a $100 bet on the underdog would result in a $150 payout if the underdog wins.

What is the winning percentage needed at -110 to break even?

A winning percentage of 52.38% is needed at -110 odds to break even in sports betting. This means that a bettor would need to win at least 52.38% of their bets to make a profit in the long run, taking into account the 10% commission taken by the bookmaker.

Get expert sports picks on every game, or if you want our very best bet premium picks by the experts, sign up for your free $60 account with a guarantee.

 

---

Most Recent Sports Handicapping

• Big Problems to Profits: How One Bettor Found the Cheat Code to Beat the Sportsbooks
• Which US States Earn the Most Taxes from Casinos and Sports Betting?
• Olympics Men’s Golf Props with Odds and Betting Predictions
• 2024 Olympic Men’s 3x3 Basketball Betting Odds and Predictions
• Olympics Medal Counts by Country: Over and Under Best Bets
• My Journey with Doc's Sports: from Fan to Fact-Finder to Family
• 2024 College World Series Betting Odds and Predictions
• WAGs of MLB: Who has the largest social media following and earning potential?
• A Statistical Analysis of NCAA Athlete NIL Earning Potential
• College Baseball National Championship Odds and Expert Predictions